Some families hang stockings. Some families go caroling. And some families, especially along the Carolina coast, stand around a hot grill on a cold night with a bushel of oysters, a stack of napkins and a loaf of French bread, and call that the holidays.
This is the easy, at-home version of that tradition. Fresh oysters on the half shell get a spoonful of garlic butter stirred with Tidewater, our organic seafood seasoning, then go over high heat until the edges curl and the butter sizzles. A snowfall of Parmesan goes on for the last two minutes, and the whole platter comes to the table still bubbling.
Oysters are a cold-weather food. They are at their plumpest and best through the winter months, which is exactly when Carolina oyster roasts happen, and exactly when you are feeding a houseful of people on Christmas Eve or New Year's Eve. Add a few lemons and a bunch of fresh parsley and that is the whole shopping list.
No grill out back? The oven broiler does the job on a sheet pan. Either way, buy one more loaf of bread than you think you need. Everybody will want to drag a piece through the butter left in the shells.

Chargrilled Oysters with Tidewater Garlic Butter
Fresh oysters on the half shell, grilled or broiled with garlic butter, organic Tidewater seafood seasoning and Parmesan until the edges curl and the butter bubbles. Serves six as an appetizer.
Ingredients
For the Tidewater garlic butter
- 1 cup (2 sticks) unsalted butter, softened
- 6 cloves garlic, finely minced
- 1 tablespoon Tidewater seafood seasoning
- 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
- 2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh flat-leaf parsley
For the oysters
- 24 fresh oysters in the shell, scrubbed and kept cold
- 3/4 cup finely grated Parmesan cheese
- 1 tablespoon chopped fresh parsley, for finishing
- 2 lemons, cut in wedges
- 1 loaf crusty French bread, sliced, for the butter
- Rock salt or crumpled foil, if using the broiler
Instructions
- Make the butter first. In a bowl, mash the softened butter with the garlic, the tablespoon of Tidewater, the lemon juice and the 2 tablespoons of parsley until it is smooth and evenly speckled. You can do this up to 3 days ahead and keep it covered in the refrigerator; let it soften on the counter for 30 minutes before using.
- Heat the grill to high, about 450 to 500 degrees, with the lid closed. If you are using the oven, move a rack about 6 inches under the broiler, turn the broiler on high, and cover a rimmed sheet pan with a layer of rock salt or crumpled foil so the shells sit level.
- Shuck the oysters. Fold a thick kitchen towel over your hand, hold an oyster flat side up, and work an oyster knife into the hinge at the pointed end. Twist to pop it open, run the knife along the top shell to cut the muscle, and pull the top shell off. Slide the knife under the oyster to loosen it, keeping it and its liquor in the deeper bottom shell.
- Set the oysters on the grill grate, or nestle them into the salt or foil on the sheet pan, so they do not tip. Spoon about 1½ teaspoons of the garlic butter onto each one, saving the rest for the end.
- Grill with the lid closed, or broil, for 4 to 5 minutes, until the butter is bubbling hard and the edges of the oysters have curled.
- Sprinkle each oyster with a big pinch of Parmesan. Cook 2 to 3 minutes more, until the cheese melts and turns golden in spots and the shell edges start to char. Oysters are done when the edges curl and they look plump and firm.
- Using tongs or a folded towel (the shells are very hot), move the oysters to a platter. Spoon a little of the remaining butter over the top, scatter on the last of the parsley, and tuck lemon wedges and bread around them.
- Serve right away, with the bread for dragging through the butter left in each shell.
Chef's notes:
Buying oysters. Ask the seafood counter for oysters that came in this week, and buy them the day you cook if you can. The shells should be closed tight, or close when you tap them; skip any that stay open. Keep them in the coldest part of the refrigerator in a bowl covered with a damp towel, never in a sealed bag or under water. Do not like shucking? Many seafood counters will shuck them for you if you ask ahead; bring a sheet pan lined with ice to carry them home.
Why Tidewater. It is our organic seafood seasoning and crab boil, 13 ingredients with organic celery first and sea salt second, warm rather than hot. Oysters bring plenty of salt of their own, so one tablespoon in a whole cup of butter is all it takes. Taste the butter before it goes on and add a pinch more only if you want it.
What is in season. Oysters are a cold-weather food, at their plumpest through the winter, which is why the Carolina oyster roast happens on chilly nights and not in July. Lemons and the other winter citrus are in their best stretch now too, and parsley grows right through a mild Southern winter.
Make it a party. Twenty-four oysters feeds six as an appetizer, about four apiece. For an oyster roast with friends, plan on a dozen per person and make one batch of butter for every two dozen. Set out a pot of our Tidewater Shrimp and Grits for the people who would rather not wrestle a shell, and read How Do You Season Shrimp? if you want to add a peel-and-eat shrimp tray.
Leftover garlic butter. It keeps a week in the refrigerator and a month in the freezer. Melt it over shrimp, toss it with hot pasta, or spread it on French bread and run it under the broiler.
On the label. Tidewater is USDA Certified Organic, made in small batches with no MSG and no fillers. The 5 oz resealable pouch, $13.49, keeps it fresh from oyster season to crab season. Free shipping over $25. The butter, cheese and bread are not ours, so those are the labels to read if anything at your table matters.