Christmas morning has its own rhythm. Somebody is up at five, somebody else will not come downstairs until the coffee is made, and the paper is everywhere before anyone has eaten a thing. What you want in the oven is something that takes five minutes of your attention, feeds a full house, and looks like you tried harder than you did.
These are that. A slice of sandwich bread, rolled thin and buttered, pressed into a muffin tin until it makes a little cup. An egg goes in each one. Twelve minutes later you have a tray of crisp, golden toast cups with a soft yolk in the middle — breakfast and the toast to dip in it, already together.
The seasoning is a pinch of The OG on every egg. It is exactly three ingredients — sea salt, organic garlic and organic black pepper — which is all an egg ever needed. A scatter of chives from the garden finishes them, and in the middle of November across the Carolinas the chives are still going strong.
The best part is what you can do the night before. Press and toast the bread cups on Christmas Eve, leave them in the tin, and in the morning all that is left is cracking twelve eggs. The grandchildren can do that part. They will want to.

Baked Egg Toast Cups with The OG
Twelve eggs baked in buttery toast cups in a muffin tin, seasoned with organic salt, pepper and garlic and finished with chives. Press the cups the night before. Serves six.
Ingredients
For the toast cups
- 12 slices soft sandwich bread, white or whole wheat
- 4 tablespoons (½ stick) unsalted butter, melted, plus a little more for the tin
- 12 paper muffin liners (optional — red ones look like Christmas)
For the eggs
- 12 large eggs
- 2 teaspoons The OG seasoning, divided (about ⅛ teaspoon on each egg, the rest to finish)
- ½ cup finely shredded sharp cheddar (optional)
To finish
- 2 tablespoons thinly sliced fresh chives
- Freshly ground black pepper
Instructions
- Heat the oven to 375°F with a rack in the middle. Brush the cups of a 12-cup muffin tin with a little melted butter, or set a paper liner in each one and butter the liners.
- Lay the bread slices on the counter and roll each one flat with a rolling pin, pressing hard — about half its original thickness. Rolled bread folds into the tin without tearing, and it bakes up crisp instead of spongy.
- Brush both sides of each slice with the melted butter. Leave the crusts on; they become the crunchy rim.
- Press a slice into each cup, letting the four corners stand up and pleating the sides against the tin so the bottom sits flat. Push firmly into the bottom edge — any gap there is where an egg will try to escape.
- Bake the empty cups 6 to 8 minutes, until the corners are golden and the bottoms look dry and set. This is the step that keeps the bottom of the cup from going soggy under the egg.
- Take the tin out. If you are using cheese, drop a pinch into the bottom of each cup. Crack each egg into a small bowl first, then slide it into a cup. If your eggs are on the big side, let a little of the white run off before it goes in, so it does not spill over the rim.
- Sprinkle each egg with about ⅛ teaspoon of The OG. It is sea salt, organic garlic and organic black pepper, so that one pinch seasons the whole egg — no extra salt needed.
- Bake 12 to 15 minutes, until the whites are completely set and opaque. At 12 minutes the yolks are soft and runny; at 15 they are jammy; give them 17 to 18 if your family likes them firm. Ovens vary, so start checking at 11.
- Let them sit in the tin 2 minutes, then run a thin knife around each cup and lift it out. Scatter the chives over the top, add the last of The OG and a grind of pepper, and serve them warm.
Chef's notes:
Do the bread the night before. Steps 1 through 5 can all happen on Christmas Eve. Once the cups are toasted, let them cool in the tin, cover it loosely with a clean towel, and leave it on the counter. In the morning, heat the oven, crack the eggs straight into the cups and bake. The cups take an extra minute or two from room temperature and come out just as crisp.
Why The OG is all the seasoning an egg needs. Salt, pepper and garlic is what most of us reach for at breakfast anyway. The OG is exactly those three — sea salt, organic garlic and organic black pepper — and nothing else, with no anti-caking agents, so it melts into the white instead of sitting on top in little white specks. The coarse pepper shows on the yolk, which is half the charm.
Let the children help. Cracking eggs into a small bowl and sliding them into the cups is a perfect job for small hands, and a broken yolk is no tragedy — it just bakes up like a little scramble. Let them do the chives with kitchen scissors, too.
Make them your own. Tuck a spoonful of crumbled cooked breakfast sausage or chopped ham under the egg. Wilt a handful of fall spinach or finely shredded collards in a little butter and put a spoonful in the bottom of each cup — both are at their sweetest in Carolina gardens right now, after the first cold nights. For a smoky version, swap the pinch of The OG for Smoke 'Em If You Got 'Em.
What goes beside them. Sliced crisp apples from the North Carolina mountains are still in season and make the plate. For a bigger spread, set these out with Holiday Glazed Ham from the night before, a bowl of Sweet and Smoky Candied Pecans and a platter of Southern Deviled Eggs for the ones who skip breakfast and go straight to the party.
On the label. The OG is USDA Certified Organic, gluten free and kosher, made in small batches with no MSG and no fillers. We recommend the 5 oz resealable pouch at $13.49 over the 3.4 oz glass jar at $9.49 — it is the better value and it reseals. The bread and cheese are not ours, so those are the labels to read if anything at your table matters. Free shipping over $25.